Migrants. To many in the UK, the word conjures up visions of unwashed, tattered scraps from the table of humanity, their worldly possessions in a small cloth bag and a scroungy look in their vacant eyes, sucking up taxpayers' blood and sweat. That a migrant (especially a non-white one) can be polished and educated, rich and successful, compatible with and even interested in local culture, seems to be a bizarre notion for the majority of Brits.
Three themes dominate the papers, day in and day out: (radical) Muslims as cultural misfits, hordes of East Europeans flooding in via EU enlargement (the job-stealing 'Polish Plumber' is the new boogeyman), and asylum seekers sponging state benefits. Sure, each of these categories has some merit, and this island nation is historically xenophobic by nature.
But in all this hysteria, the political parties in charge enact misguided kneejerk populist measures, and the one migrant group who actually does nothing but benefit the economy gets the stick.
Work Permit (WP) and Highly Skilled Migrant Program (HSMP) visa holders [I'm one of the latter] are, I would hazard, some of the best and brightest young people working in the UK, across nationalities. The WP is an employer-sponsored 5-year work visa (sort of like the US H1-B) while HSMP is a points based system that rewards youth, higher education and work experience, and above-average earning power. You needed 65 points to be eligible for the scheme, which would give you a one-year employer-independent work visa, extendable for a further three years. Both WPs and HSMPs could, after completing four years in the UK, apply for ILR (Indefinite Leave to Remain) - the equivalent of permanent residency. After a minimum of one year on the ILR, an application for British citizenship could be made.
All this WAS the case. This year, the Home Office introduced two major changes. The first was pushing up the timeframe for ILR (and therefore eventual citizenship) from 4 years to 5. The second, more fundamental change, was a sudden and complete revision of the HSMP system last week, with some points categories scrapped, new ones introduced and more gradient points allocations. All fine and dandy (objectively speaking it's definitely an improvement on the older system) - but it will apply not only to fresh applications but also to extensions for those already here.
Now it doesn't directly affect me for now, cos I already got my extension till 2010 a couple of months ago. But thousands of others have been caught in the lurch. After investing much or all of their life savings to come here, sometimes with familes, find work and set up a new life in the UK - the application form even asks you to pledge that you will 'make the UK your main home' - they go to renew the initial one-year visa and presto chango, they suddenly don't meet the new criteria. What now for them? Shut shop and fuck off? Is this the reassurance that the government of your newly adopted country gives you - at any point they can change rules and tell you to piss off?
I feel especially sorry for those who got caught in between the two rule changes - say, someone who would have qualified for ILR in a few weeks' time suddenly has to wait another year, and deciding to knuckle down and wait it out, then gets slammed with another rule change, which is effectively a deportation order for those who can't make the new bar.
There is already talk of legal action on immigration boards, but I don't know what will come of it, because at the end of the day, all said and done, this is Britain and the British are free to do what they like to foreigners in their country. Indeed, even when known radicals like Abu Hamza are given state benefits of £30k a year and preach hatred at the mosques every week, even when 50,000-plus asylum seekers and their dependents are given that precious piece of paper every year, the government is free to throw as many obstacles and hurdles as they can at their most skilled, hard-working, law-abiding group of residents. Freedom and democracy, yeah!


11 Comments:
It's senseless. I can only guess that a backlash from skilled, hard-working people would probably be less violent than a backlash from unemployed radicals..
aye caramba..i feel terrible for the people who came so close and now have to wait..its completely unfair.
what can they do eh? they cant leave either and the government probably knows they have no choice but to stick it out..
Go America.
So well explained and put across.But the situtaion is really shite.It is even worse if you are a doctor, they have completely changed the training system which means not only does one battle the visa issues they are also stranded with their training midway.
raindrop: it really is.. somebody up there is not thinking things fully thru when they create a new system.. and the human fallout obviously does not touch them.
mahi: they have to leave! if they cannot renew the visa or switch to WP (requiring employer effort), out they go!
mediocretes: hi! well, the US doesn't even HAVE a points-based immigration system as of now, as do canada, uk, australia and nz..
educated: i know - a damn shame it is! i read about that too, but didnt blog about it cos it wasn't my visa category and so wasn't as involved.. :-/
Precisely. Go America.
Oh, and Hi! :)
Immigration policy will never be uniform. The points system is most practical, but then screws those people out chasing the proverbial 'American Dream', and the US at least doesn't want to give up on those.
Why? In a lot of places I've been, and you see it on TV as well, there are a few jobs the locals aren't willing to do, so migrants help out. But when they do, the locals are up in arms.
All countries are xenophobic in their own way, but unless the migrants are willing to be assimilated (read behave like them), there aren't many places that will be happy to see them.
Testing.
Thanks for making me crap bricks for about an hour, mate. It's the extension thing that gave me the heebiejeebies. I've spent a considerable amount of personal time and energy trying to help doctors caught in the crossfire, and I think it was a despicably shameful thing to push the visa changes overnight with no consultation in such a calculatedly mercenary manner.
The funny thing was that when we tried to get some heavyweight lobbying support, first generation Indian doctors (whose kids were now UK grads and hence, competing with better and quicker Indian grads) came out with the same lines a White Male Doctor would have come out with 30 yrs ago i.e. sod the bastards. Just goes on to show that some things never change. Like human nature. Comforting.
A similar closing of ranks is happening in academia, simply because, well, non-Europeans are fucking smarter and, specifically, harder working. Does this sound racist? Yes. Is it the truth? Yes. Do schoolkids from Indian and Chinese backgrounds do better than anyone else. Yes.
drunken master: inherent xenophobia or not, if a country/civilisation believes that it is a lawful democracy, and takes pride in it, act like it, i say, and support the legal residents who respect those very values.
nevermind: but as with every visa category, some undeserving louts with no skills and crap english and faked degrees will go sour everything for the rest..
Post a Comment
<< Home